Without Christmas, There Would Be No United States

As a Christian holiday, Christmas is foundational to America’s original character. It’s affected our founders’ understanding of human nature.

By Scott Powell – December 23, 2022


Across cultures, people have sought to flee oppression and escape persecution from the beginning of recorded history. A recurring theme in Western classical literature and in modern classics such as Superman and Disney originals, which revolve around the struggle between good and evil, is the need and critical role for a rescuer or savior.

The ultimate rescuer and savior for mankind would be a “messiah,” who would vanquish evil, oppression and falsehood once and for all. It is no accident that only Christianity has its roots and its entire reason for being in the messiah Jesus Christ. No other religion makes the claim that it was founded by a messiah.

Meaning of Christmas

Without a doubt, Christmas is a magical time of year not just because of the appeal of peace and a guiding star, as well as decorations, light displays, and volumes of wonderful music, but specifically because it marks the birth of Jesus Christ, who came into this world as the son of God, the Messiah and savior for all who accept him. Christmas is really about internal and eternal things rather than external and temporal matters.

Many people think approaching God is impossible. For them, Christianity appears to be a religion with questionable appeal because of the perception that it is like all the other religions that require giving up certain bad habits and behaviors and performing good works in order to approach God. Surprise, surprise: Christ reminds us in Matthew 11:30 that, “My yoke is easy, and My burden is light.”

When a learned Jewish Pharisee whose life revolved around living up to stressful demands of the Mosaic law asked Jesus which was the greatest commandment in the law, Jesus answered simply that if we love God and love our neighbor as ourselves, we will have fulfilled all the laws.

Even non-believers know there was something different about Jesus. For one thing, Jesus Christ, being God, affected history with such an impact that He split time, dividing all human activities and events into happening before his coming (called B.C.) or after his coming (called A.D.). Christ had to have had a supernatural impact for non-Christians around the world to agree to dividing history in two.

Why People Can Trust that Christ Was Truly Born

First, Jesus Christ is more historically verifiable than any other person who lived in that ancient time and era—including such luminaries as the Roman emperors, Aristotle or Alexander the Great—because of the number of eyewitness accounts that were recorded in writing within a generation of his life.

Christ is the only person in history who was pre-announced starting 1,000 years before he was born, with 18 different prophets from the Old Testament between tenth and the fourth centuries B.C. predicting his coming birth, life, and death. Hundreds of years later, the circumstances of Christ’s birth, life and death validated those prophecies in surprisingly accurate detail. This is unique to Jesus Christ—no one else in human history.

Second, Christ lived, and not only demonstrated his otherworldly power to heal and perform the ultimate miracle of bringing the dead back to life, but he set the absolute highest standard of love possible—being willing to die to give life to others. As Jesus prophesied, his resurrection confirmed God’s power and plan. It provided “seeing is believing” evidence by bringing Jesus back from the dead and buried in a tomb to being alive, thus providing living proof of who He is.

In fact, Jesus made ten separate appearances to his disciples between the resurrection and his ascension into Heaven, a period of 40 days. Some of those appearances were to individual disciples, some were to several disciples at the same time, and once even to 500 at one time. This was not hearsay, but a matter of record of multiple separate eyewitness accounts that were recorded in writing.

Third, no other religion teaches that God became flesh. In other religions God is too high, otherworldly, and pure to be accessible in terms of having a communion with believers. In Christianity, God had his Son born in the humbleness of a stable and had him raised in Nazareth, a small and very poor town that was one of the lowest in social status in Israel.

Unlike other religious paths that require certain formalities and good works, the Christian approaches God not by his or her works but by simply a humble recognition that Christ gave his life for our sins—that he paid the price for us—and that through Christ we can have a direct relationship with God.

There Would Be No Constitution without Christianity

As a Christian holiday, Christmas is foundational to America’s original character. If Christ had never been born and died the way He did, all of history would have been different. For one thing, neither Columbus nor the Pilgrims would have received or have been motivated by the good news of salvation through Christ to explore or establish a new community with a higher purpose in the New World.

There would never have been a constitutional government created in the way and time that it was in America, without two necessary conditions: First, the foundation of recognizing man’s unalienable rights of freedom and equality that came out of the teachings of Christ, more fully recognized in the Protestant Reformation of the 16th century.

Second, the unprecedented collection of Christian human genius that came together—rather amazingly at the same time—people we call the Founding Fathers, who were deeply influenced by Christianity. The founders knew the potential depravity that exists in everyone can lead to abuse of power and tyranny. For this reason, they structured the government with checks and balances between the three branches of government, but also through the federalist system of division of power between the states and the federal government.

The constitutional republic formed by the Founders provided for and protected individual rights of freedom and independence such that America achieved material prosperity more rapidly than any other prior civilization. Additionally, the American constitutional framework enabled people to move closer to the divine image in which all people are created free and equal more than they would have achieved under any prior system.

History shows that so many levels of human advancement were made possible by God who became man, born in the humble circumstances of a dirty stable in the small village of Bethlehem, a speck in the vast Roman Empire. While that empire would crumble and fall, Jesus, who had neither an army nor won any military battles, went on to become the Lord and Savior for people who believe all over the world. For, as He said, “My Kingdom is not of this world.”

This article is a vignette adapted from the author’s latest acclaimed book, “Rediscovering America,” which was No. 1 new release in history for eight straight weeks at Amazon.

Scott S. Powell is senior fellow at Discovery Institute. His new book, “Rediscovering America”, has been the number one on Amazon among new releases in the history genre for eight weeks. Reach him at scottp@discovery.org.

The Federalist